Social studies teachers aiming to connect real-life current events to classroom learning won鈥檛 have to look far this fall: The presidential campaign will come to a crescendo during the first semester of 2024-25 school year and culminate with the election on Nov. 5.
Teaching students about these cornerstones of the American political process seems like a no-brainer. But this election cycle, it won鈥檛 be a given.
Schools tend to be microcosms of our politically polarized nation, and it鈥檚 not uncommon for families鈥� political beliefs to be at odds with those of educators. This鈥攁long with laws in some states that restrict how teachers can talk about controversial topics鈥攈as some teachers, and entire school districts, hesitant to wade into potentially fraught subjects like the presidential campaign.
The 2024 presidential election has some ready-made lessons for students, with President Joe Biden鈥檚 exit from the race, former President Donald Trump鈥檚 recent felony conviction and an assassination attempt against him, and the historic nature of Vice President Kamala Harris鈥� candidacy. However, the matchup that鈥檚 taking shape between Trump and Harris is steeped with inflammatory rhetoric and personal attacks, and tensions among voters are high.
Still, social studies educators and experts share why they believe covering the presidential campaign is worth the effort鈥攅ven in a hotly contentious political climate鈥攁nd offer some insight on how best to navigate it effectively.
Kids are curious: an argument for teacher-led discussions on current events
鈥淪tudents are deeply curious about their world,鈥� said Christie Nold, a high school social studies teacher in Vermont鈥檚 South Burlington school district. 鈥淚 believe that students are regularly trying to make sense of what鈥檚 happening both at home and overseas.鈥�
She also believes teachers are in a good spot to respond to their curiosity. 鈥淎s educators, we can either create space in our classrooms for facilitated conversation, or know that the conversations are happening on TikTok, in bathrooms, and hallways without facilitation and support.鈥�
Former middle school teacher Lawrence Paska agrees that kids are curious. And they come to class with questions.
鈥淚f I were teaching a world history class in grade 10, and we鈥檙e about to learn about Chinese empires today, and breaking news is happening, kids may ask about it. And you have to make that decision: Do I stop what I鈥檓 doing to kind of put things in context?鈥� said Paska, who is now the executive director of the National Council for the Social Studies.
The answer may lie in judging the current event鈥檚 historical significance, and whether taking time to teach it will further students鈥� knowledge, explains Paska.
鈥淩ight now we鈥檙e in this historic moment where a candidate who is clearly running for renomination has stepped aside,鈥� Paska said. 鈥淜ids will have a lot of questions about that, and we do have an opportunity to put that in context, how other presidents have also stepped aside in the middle [of a campaign].鈥�
Will teachers be talking about the presidential campaign?
Given kids鈥� curiosity and the educationally relevant nature of the presidential campaign, will teachers cover it in class? It depends on whom you ask. Nold said she 鈥渁bsolutely鈥� will.
鈥淎s a social studies teacher, there are so many 鈥榙ays after.鈥� It might be the day after an election, the day after a mass shooting, the day after war breaks out,鈥� she said. 鈥淚n each of these cases, students are often looking for answers and come with curiosity.鈥�
Although Nold said she doesn鈥檛 always fully understand or have all the answers when big news breaks, she attempts to come to school 鈥減repared with resources, information, and structures for conversation.鈥�
Jennifer Morgan, a social studies teacher at West Salem Middle School in Wisconsin, works in what she describes as a 鈥渞eally, really bright red鈥� district.
鈥淚 don鈥檛 necessarily share their [students鈥� and families鈥橾 viewpoints in most cases,鈥� said Morgan, president of the National Council for the Social Studies. But she will mention the presidential campaign and election in her class.
鈥淚 plan to stick to the facts,鈥� she said.
Some of Morgan鈥檚 professional peers who work in similarly polarized environments won鈥檛 venture that far.
鈥淪ome of the teachers I鈥檝e talked to have been told by their administrators not to teach it. And others are just really nervous about teaching it, because they鈥檙e fearful of what will come out of students鈥� mouths,鈥� she said.
Strategies for navigating political鈥攁nd divisive鈥攖opics
Students tend to be curious about current events鈥攁s well as their teachers鈥� take on them. That鈥檚 normal, said Paska. But he encourages teachers to turn this curiosity back to students鈥� own perspective.
鈥淚 was a middle school social studies teacher, and kids would sometimes ask me: 鈥榃ho would you vote for?鈥� I would tell them that it鈥檚 not about who I would vote for,鈥� Paska said. 鈥淚t鈥檚 really about the issues and what鈥檚 important to you in deciding who should be elected.鈥�
Paska stresses that the role of social studies teachers isn鈥檛 to indoctrinate students into a particular way of thinking about politics.
鈥淚t is never our mission to come in and tell you how to vote, who to vote for, why one position is better than another,鈥� he said. 鈥淚 tell people: [Social studies] teachers are here to teach students how to think, not what to think.鈥�
K-12 in a 2nd Trump Term: Project 2025, a detailed policy agenda assembled by allies of the former president, outlines plans to dramatically scale back the federal role in education. Here鈥檚 how.
Kamala Harris鈥� Education Record: The vice president has touched education policy since her days as a prosecutor. What she鈥檚 said and done on K-12.
The GOP鈥檚 2024 Education Platform: We break down the party鈥檚 nine key education positions in its official platform. Here鈥檚 what the party has in mind.
鈥楪od Knows We Don鈥檛 Pay You Enough': Kamala Harris rallied teachers in one of her first campaign speeches. Here鈥檚 what she said.
