Student mental health is at the forefront of educators鈥� minds these days after two years of pandemic-driven stress and disruption鈥攂ut district leaders forget about the adults in the school building at their own peril, experts say.
About 1 in 4 teachers said they were experiencing symptoms of depression in an early 2021 survey by the RAND Corp., a research group and think tank. In a separate survey, RAND also found that most secondary school principals were experiencing frequent job-related stress鈥攁nd one of their big stressors was supporting teachers鈥� mental health and well-being.
Left unaddressed, that stress could lead to a massive exodus of educators. Despite that, only a third of district and school leaders said they have made counselors or mental health services available to staff since the start of the pandemic or added to the mental health services already offered, according to a nationally representative EdWeek Research Center survey of nearly 900 educators conducted in January and February.
Forty-four percent of those who responded said they have offered or increased their offerings of professional development on self-care, which educators and experts say is not enough on its own to address clinical mental health needs. And 17 percent said they have not taken any steps to address staff mental health needs during the pandemic even though their current offerings are inadequate.
Targeted mental health support for staff is crucial for a thriving school environment, experts say.
鈥淭eacher well-being is incredibly important, not only for them but for their students鈥� learning experiences as well,鈥� said Leigh McLean, an assistant research professor at the Center for Research in Education & Social Policy at the University of Delaware.
Her research has found that teachers with depression spend less time doing whole-class instruction鈥攍ikely because it鈥檚 more demanding and energy-intensive鈥攁nd have fewer warm and responsive interactions with students. They also spend less time planning and organizing their lessons.
Having structural supports for teacher mental health will ultimately benefit everyone in the school building, including school leaders. If teachers and students have access to counseling and other mental health support, that鈥檚 a heavy burden taken off their principals鈥� backs.
Building a culture of support
McLean鈥檚 research has found that teachers鈥� mental health and commitment to their career is better protected when they experience more support and autonomy from school leaders. Having colleagues whom teachers can turn to for help also boosts mental health, she said.
In preliminary research, McLean found that during the pandemic, certain teachers are struggling with their mental health more than others: teachers of color, early-career teachers, and those in high-needs schools.
Ronn Nozoe, the chief executive officer of the National Association of Secondary School Principals, has advocated for districts and schools to use some of their federal COVID-19 relief funds to set up targeted support programs for school leaders鈥� mental health.
However, there鈥檚 a huge demand for mental health care professionals nationally, and school districts may be competing with others with deeper pockets.
Additionally, Nozoe said, even school leaders who know the importance of mental health care are more willing to spend available funds on students and teachers than themselves. And there鈥檚 still a stigma around mental health, he said.
鈥淚t鈥檚 not for lack of want, it鈥檚 not for lack of ideas,鈥� Nozoe said. 鈥淚t鈥檚 really a lack of available professionals who are willing and qualified to provide these kinds of services to help kids and families and ultimately educators.鈥�
How can school leaders best respond to these pressures? One way is to take stock of their resources, make workers aware of them, and ensure they鈥檙e available.
In May, the Colorado School of Public Health鈥檚 Center for Health, Work, & Environment partnered with the University of Colorado鈥檚 Depression Center to 鈥攁n online tool kit for employers to take stock of the management and workplace strategies they have in place to address the mental health of their staff. Employers take a survey that assesses their workplace culture, employee benefits, education and training, and equity and accessibility.
The module is open to all employers in the country, including schools. So far, five districts in Colorado have signed on, including the Denver public schools, said David Shapiro, the program manager for Health Links at CHWE, which distributes the module. These districts typically score high on employee benefits for mental health, he said, but there was a need for more education and training.
For example, all school employees should learn how to access available supports for their own mental health needs. And schools should establish peer-support programs, so some employees learn 鈥渉ow to be an ally or 鈥榓skable鈥� adult for their colleague to get the support they need,鈥� Shapiro said. He recommends that districts train certain teachers or other staff members so there are 鈥渃hampions for mental health within the school district鈥� who aren鈥檛 in leadership positions. (After all, it can be intimidating to confide in your boss, Shapiro noted.)
Also, school and district leaders should make sure they鈥檙e sharing information about mental health benefits in an equitable way, he said. Some school staffers, like bus drivers, might not check their emails as frequently as teachers鈥攕o principals should consider delivering the information through nonelectronic methods, like posters or mailers, too. Also, the information should be available in multiple languages.
We are not a place that cares about mental health unless we care about mental health for everybody, and that includes our adults on campus.
And school leaders must create a workplace culture where people can be open about mental health, he said.
It鈥檚 important to have 鈥減eople be willing to share their stories, and I think this starts with leaders,鈥� Shapiro said. 鈥淸They can tell staff], 鈥楾his pandemic has been challenging for my own mental health鈥攈ere鈥檚 how it impacted me, and I鈥檝e used my mental health benefits [to get help]鈥�. The more we can build the story of mental health, the more we can spread awareness, the more we can reduce stigma.鈥�
Partnerships to Uplift Communities Schools, or PUC Schools, which serves students in northeast Los Angeles and the San Fernando Valley in California, has counseling sessions available for students, teachers, and principals. Max Valadez, the principal of PUC Lakeview Charter Academy, said those sessions have helped him navigate challenges in his personal life and served him in his role as a school leader.
鈥淎s a principal, there are so many moving pieces, sometimes I just need to talk to somebody who is not going to judge or anything like that鈥攋ust to let me know if I am doing things correctly or if I鈥檓 not,鈥� Valadez said.
Modeling and demonstrating concern for mental health
When Sarah Broome was the executive director of Thrive Academy, a statewide public boarding school in Baton Rouge, La., everybody on staff knew when her weekly therapy appointment was because she spoke about it so freely. Broome, who resigned as the executive director in June 2021 and is now an education consultant, said that openness about mental health helped lessen any stigma for other adults in the building to get help.
When students returned to campus in August 2020 after the initial coronavirus shutdowns, Paul Sampson, Thrive鈥檚 principal at the time, and Chelsea Trice, the school鈥檚 head social worker, decided that it wasn鈥檛 enough to prioritize students鈥� mental health鈥攖hey needed to offer robust support to educators, too. Broome agreed.
鈥淲e are not a place that cares about mental health unless we care about mental health for everybody, and that includes our adults on campus,鈥� Broome said. 鈥淭eaching was really hard before the pandemic, and it鈥檚 only gotten exponentially more so. Teachers need places to process [their feelings].鈥�
The school began offering teachers the option to participate in individual therapy sessions with school social workers every other week. (Thrive later hired contract social workers, in case teachers felt more comfortable talking with someone who wasn鈥檛 on staff.) The social workers kept all information shared during the sessions confidential but also compiled top-level trends and shared that data with administrators.
Moreover, the school held weekly group therapy meetings where teachers could talk about specific student academic and social-emotional needs and discuss the best strategies to take. The meetings allowed administrators to hear teachers鈥� concerns and address them immediately, Broome said.
But none of this work was an overnight fix, she said. And teachers were able to go to these therapy sessions because school leadership had built significant amounts of teacher planning time into the schedule.
鈥淵ou can鈥檛 mental-health-support your way out of structural challenges,鈥� Broome said. 鈥淭here is literally nothing you can do for a teacher who is not able to go to the bathroom all day.鈥�
Valadez, the Lakeview Charter Academy principal, has also been trying to find ways to reduce the strain on his teachers, especially those who鈥檝e had to fill in for colleagues who鈥檙e absent because of COVID-19.
A few nonteaching staff members have recently obtained their teacher-substitute permits, and the charter school network also contracted with a substitute company, which allows the school to have a substitute ready if a teacher gives two weeks鈥� notice that he or she will be absent. Both changes reduce the frequency teachers will be called upon to fill in for peers鈥攅liminating a huge stressor.
Outside resources and partnerships can help
The PUC charter schools network relies heavily on graduate interns studying American family therapy鈥攁 cheaper way to staff counseling programs for students and educators, since the interns are not paid and are getting experience and credit toward their degrees.
That program was started in the early 2000s and is run by Christine Sartiaguda, a licensed marital and family therapist who also has a doctorate in education. It has grown from Sartiaguda and 16 interns to include 50 to 60 clinical interns annually, working under a team of five licensed clinical supervisors. While the program was initially geared to support students, teachers and school leaders were always able to tap into it. But the outreach to teachers and principals became more systematic since the pandemic.
鈥淲ith COVID, we realized that it wasn鈥檛 a matter of waiting for the teachers to ask, it was about us being proactive鈥攔ecognizing and just seeing the impact COVID has had on teachers trying to pivot to online learning,鈥� she said. 鈥淭hey look tired, they look stressed, and we just need to provide the support and hope they take advantage of it.鈥�
Just one month after the initial shutdown in spring 2020, Sartiaguda started offering teacher-support groups via Zoom. By fall of the 2020-21 school year, those groups were available at all the network鈥檚 campuses. Staff meetings include meditation and mindfulness exercises. Professional development has self-care for teachers鈥斺�渟imple, simple ways that they can fit in one minute of mindfulness in their day, just to kind of disconnect from the chaos of having to practice and teach,鈥� she said.
Sartiaguda鈥檚 staff can tailor supports to meet individual schools鈥� needs.
鈥淚f a [school] leader comes to us and says, 鈥業鈥檝e had a lot of my teachers who鈥檝e experienced deaths in their families since COVID began, can you do a specific group just addressing grief and loss?,鈥� the answer is yes,鈥� she said. 鈥淲hatever the need is, we can accommodate it.鈥�
Because the interns are receiving their degrees in marital and family therapy, their primary focus in schools remains getting experience in those areas.
鈥淏ut we have really restructured our program to include the teacher piece,鈥� Sartiaguda said. In addition, her team provides referrals to low-cost counselors and therapists in the community.
Getting buy-in from educators
Although teachers are stressed, not all are taking advantage of the mental health resources the PUC network is offering, Sartiaguda said.
After the end of a long day, some teachers did not want to log on to Zoom for another hour鈥攅ven if they knew the benefits, she said.
鈥淲e do try sometimes to offer it during lunchtime, and sometimes teachers say, 鈥榊ou know what. I just want to eat my lunch [or] I need to prep.鈥欌�� But she added, 鈥渨hat we emphasize is, it is here if you change your mind. If you reach a point of, 鈥榃ell, I actually want to make time for this support,鈥� it is absolutely available.鈥�
Valadez, who became the principal of PUC Lakeview Charter Academy just a few months before the pandemic, said about 20 percent of the school鈥檚 teachers have taken advantage of the on-site counselors over the last two years. Some needed help with family issues such as deaths in the family and anxiety related to a child heading off to college amid a pandemic.
Valadez knows that some teachers may be uncomfortable speaking with him and the assistant principal about professional and personal problems, so he always lets them know that 鈥渢here鈥檚 somebody else they can talk to.鈥�
Jennifer Lopez, a teacher at PUC Community Charter Elementary School in Los Angeles, started a self-care committee shortly after the shutdown in March 2020, with the support of Principal Jocelyn Velez, to help teachers focus on their well-being, develop coping skills, and provide other support, amid the pandemic.
Both say the committee will become a permanent part of the school going forward.
鈥淥ne of the teachers said, 鈥楾his is the one meeting I can miss but the one meeting I don鈥檛 want to miss because I need this type of support,鈥欌�夆�� Velez said. 鈥淭hat鈥檚 always really nice to hear.鈥�
The topics Lopez tackles during the meetings, which initially were held over Zoom, come from teacher surveys and feedback. She鈥檚 also organized book studies on wellbeing and hosted sessions on yoga and financial wellness.
Now back on campus, the group continues to meet weekly. Administrators have also joined in, including on a recent nature walk.
鈥淚t鈥檚 been really cool to bring that community back to campus,鈥� Lopez said. 鈥淚t鈥檚 been really awesome to have our admin support and [have] them thinking of ways for us to take care of our mental health.鈥�
Weekly emails go beyond self-help pick-me-ups, Velez said, and provide concrete tips and techniques that teachers can use to weather this traumatic period.
This semester, the group is studying Tina Boogren鈥檚 180 Days of Self-Care for Busy Educators, a guide to helping educators find the right balance.
Lopez recently hosted a 鈥渧ision board鈥� activity to help staff members visualize both their professional and personal intentions.
鈥淚t was nice to take that time in our busy lives to sit down, cut out pictures, and print out pictures, and sit down with our staff members, and talk about our goals in a very genuine way,鈥� said Velez. 鈥淚n a time of chaos, ... allowing ourselves to be ourselves, bringing that person behind the professional into the classrooms with a group of teachers鈥攖hat was very impactful, I think.鈥�
Principals can create an environment in which teachers know they can go to their bosses and say they need to take a break, Velez said. She has been encouraging teachers to take the day off when they need to and she鈥檚 been modeling that behavior to staff.
鈥淲e have a trusting relationship at our school and we鈥檝e built that culture鈥攊t鈥檚 taken some time, but it鈥檚 that trust,鈥� Velez said.
For example, a teacher, who is pregnant, recently texted Velez one night saying that her feet were swollen.
Velez responded, 鈥淵ou can take the day off tomorrow,鈥� she said. 鈥淚 would just need to know so I can get a sub. But we want you to be healthy, we want you to take care of yourself. We want you to follow the doctor鈥檚 orders. So, if it means extra rest鈥攖ake the day off.
鈥淚t鈥檚 really letting them know it鈥檚 going to be OK,鈥� she said. 鈥淚 just want you to take care of yourself.鈥�
