The Independence school district just east of Kansas City, Mo., this Friday will wrap up its first school year implementing a four-days-a-week schedule. From Superintendent Dale Herl鈥檚 perspective, the switch has been a massive success.
A significant majority of parents and staff that they鈥檙e happy with the current schedule and wouldn鈥檛 want to switch back. Finding qualified candidates for positions like teachers, bus drivers, and nurses was easier than ever in the last 15 years.
鈥淎ll of the research shows that the most important thing for student learning is having a high quality, certified teacher in your classrooms,鈥� Herl said. 鈥淏y us going to a four-day week, we鈥檝e been able to ensure that that has occurred.鈥�
With roughly 14,000 students, Independence is the largest of more than 120 districts in the state, and one of the largest in the country, to adopt a four-day school week in recent years.
However, some state lawmakers aren鈥檛 convinced the model is worth promoting. Missouri that will eventually require large school districts like Independence to secure voter approval once per decade to continue operating on a four-day week schedule. The state is also offering an annual financial bonus鈥攊nitially equivalent to one percent of the district鈥檚 allocation of state aid鈥攆or districts that maintain or switch back to a five-day schedule.
Herl is in touch with many of the dozens of superintendents in Missouri districts that operate four days a week. None of them, he said, is considering restoring the fifth day as a result of the new policies.
But Paul Fregeau, superintendent of the 10,300-student Fox district south of St. Louis, said the new law helped convince him and his colleagues to put off for at least a year any decision about whether the district should move to a four-day school week. His district is experiencing a budget deficit, and the extra cash from the state will help soften the financial blow.
He also wants to see how the four-day school week fares among voters in other parts of the state.
鈥淚t鈥檒l be interesting to see the communities that have been in it for a while, what their votes are,鈥� Fregeau said. 鈥淭hat鈥檒l send a strong message one way or the another.鈥�
Some states want to discourage four-day school weeks
The debate over four-day school weeks in Missouri reflects broader disagreement across the country about the benefits and drawbacks of the approach.
Most of the nation鈥檚 13,000 public school districts in the U.S. still open their doors to students five days a week. But in recent years, just shy of 1,000 districts in states like , , , , , , , , and have moved to a four-day weekly schedule, often dropping either Monday or Friday. Some individual schools have joined in too鈥攖he Lafayette school district in Indiana a four-day school week for Vinton Elementary starting next year.
Some states are moving to increase flexibility for school district schedules. Late last year, Pennsylvania to allow school districts to operate 180 days per year or between 900 and 990 hours per year, rather than having to satisfy both requirements.
Others aren鈥檛 so eager. New Mexico school districts recently and convinced a judge to that . A lawmaker in Louisiana on school weeks of less than five days. And in Idaho, about whether a new state funding opportunity for improving their facilities hinges on their school system remaining open five days a week.
Researchers continue to paint a mixed picture of the effects of four-day school weeks. A found no significant difference in academic achievement regardless of the length of the school week. A , meanwhile, found small decreases in the growth of student achievement in districts with four-day weeks.
The model is growing more popular, though. Two-thirds of teachers, principals, and district leaders who responded to an EdWeek Research Center survey in December said they鈥檇 be either slightly or much more willing to accept a job offer from a district with a four-day school week. Seventy percent of teacher respondents said they support a four-day school week.
Each district has a unique approach to a shortened week
No two four-day school weeks look exactly alike.
Some districts look to four-day school weeks to save money. The Fox schools, for instance, estimates it would annually save $300,000 to $400,000 on transportation costs with one fewer day of bus operations, Fregeau said.
Others see the model as a tool to recruit and retain teachers who might otherwise seek districts that offer higher pay.
Herl told colleagues and community members upfront that his approach to a four-day school week likely wouldn鈥檛 reduce the district鈥檚 annual expenses, and might even raise them. But the district was struggling mightily to retain teachers, in line with broader statewide trends鈥攍ess than half of new teachers are staying in the same district for four years, according to state data.
A four-day workweek enticed some candidates who might otherwise have gravitated towards nearby districts that pay more, he said. The district extended the school day by 35 minutes to ensure students don鈥檛 lose instructional time.
The timing of the school year also factors into some districts鈥� decision-making around the length of the school week. In North Carolina, the Charlotte-Mecklenburg school district is if the state doesn鈥檛 agree to the district鈥檚 proposal to start the 2024-25 school year earlier than the law currently permits.
Some districts, like Independence, pay staff who work five days a week the same amount for working one day less. Others, like the rural Warren County, Mo., district west of St. Louis, dock a portion of their pay to reflect their reduced hours.
Even so, the new funding stream for districts operating five days a week didn鈥檛 convince the 3,000-student Warren County district to make the switch, said Superintendent Gregg Klinginsmith. State law requires districts to spend the money only on raising teacher salaries.
That wouldn鈥檛 have made up for the additional costs of transportation and other expenses for a fifth day of in-person instruction. And it wouldn鈥檛 have made staff more likely to stick around, he said.
鈥淲e asked teachers, 鈥楧o you want to give up your Mondays and make $500 more a year?鈥欌�� Klinginsmith said. 鈥淭he resounding answer was no.鈥�
New policies could be costly for districts
Tensions are rising between districts and states over who should have the final say on four-day school weeks.
A bill in Minnesota would from the state education department before adopting the four-day school week.
In Missouri, districts in cities or counties with more than 30,000 residents will have to put the four-day school week to a community vote once every ten years, starting with the 2025-26 school year.
The Fox district will have to pay the state $145,000 just to get the item on the local ballot, Fregeau said.
鈥淔or us, that鈥檚 two teachers,鈥� he said. That doesn鈥檛 include the cost of creating written materials to help community members understand the stakes of the election.
Some voters may already be forming their own opinions on the four-day workweek, which has gained mainstream attention in recent years as some companies in the U.S. and beyond have shaved a day off their weekly calendars. Sen. Bernie Sanders, I-Vermont, that would make the four-day workweek standard across America.
In districts that have adopted the four-day week, parents tend to worry about how their children are going to spend the extra day at home. But the anxiety tends to dissipate once the schedule takes hold, district leaders in Missouri said.
That鈥檚 in part because the four-day school week can be a misnomer. Many districts use the day off to offer supplemental instruction for struggling students, professional development opportunities for staff, or partner with community colleges on new course offerings.
鈥淲hen you make the move, people are very concerned, I get a lot of feedback,鈥� Klinginsmith said. 鈥淏ut since we鈥檝e made the switch, I don鈥檛 think I鈥檝e had a phone call in five years on people that are upset about it.鈥�
