澳门跑狗论坛

A panel created by President Donald Trump to help prevent future school shootings called Tuesday for getting rid of Obama administration guidance aimed at making sure students of color and students with disabilities aren鈥檛 disciplined more harshly than their peers.

U.S. Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos, who leads the Federal Commission on School Safety, said the report encourages schools 鈥渢o seriously consider the option of partnering with local law enforcement in the training and arming of school personnel.鈥� But the report did not suggest that arming school staff鈥攕omething supported by Trump鈥攂ecome a federal mandate.

Instead, it recommends that districts offer incentives for retired law enforcement officials, military veterans, and others with firearms training to serve as educators, as well as ease teacher certification so that they can more easily join the profession.

In what appears to be the only nod to gun control, the 180-page report endorses state adoption of 鈥渆xtreme risk protection orders,鈥� which temporarily restrict access to firearms from individuals found to be a danger to themselves or others.

The report also endorses better access to mental health services 鈥渟o that people can receive the treatment they need,鈥� DeVos said in an early-morning call with reporters. That includes working with Congress to update health and school privacy laws.

And it calls on journalists to 鈥渂e more responsible in their coverage of school shootings鈥� and not to publish images or names of the perpetrators, DeVos said on the call.

But the commission did not recommend new age restrictions for the purchase of firearms鈥攐ne of the few gun-related issues Trump asked the panel to consider in response to calls for gun control after the Feb. 14 school shooting in Parkland, Fla.

Later in the day, Trump, DeVos, and the other commission members met with survivors and families of victims from the Parkland shootings, as well as from the 2012 massacre at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Conn.

Trump said most school shootings take less than five minutes, which is why 鈥渋t鈥檚 critical to have armed personnel available at a moment鈥檚 notice,鈥� he added. 鈥淭hese are people, teachers in many cases, that are the highest-trained that you can get. People that are natural to firearms. People who know how to handle them. People that have great experience and on top of the experience have taken courses. 鈥� Also they love our students 鈥� and in loving our students, they want to fight for our students.鈥�

Process Concerns

The commission originally consisted of three cabinet secretaries in addition to DeVos: Alex Azar, the secretary of Health and Human Services; Kirstjen M. Nielsen, the secretary of Homeland Security; and Jeff Sessions, the attorney general. (Sessions resigned in November, and his former chief of staff, Matthew Whitaker, is now serving as acting attorney general and as a member of the commission.)

From the get-go, education advocates were concerned about the safety commission鈥檚 mandate and its process for garnering feedback from the K-12 community. And they worried that the four Trump cabinet officials wouldn鈥檛 be able to consider gun safety issues outside of a political context, and didn鈥檛 have any hands-on experience in schools. U.S. Sen. Patty Murray, D-Wash., the top Democrat on the Senate education committee, even sent a letter to DeVos asking how much sway the National Rifle Association had on the panel鈥檚 activities and mission.

The panel set up an email address to solicit ideas from the public and held four 鈥渓istening sessions鈥� around the country, at which members of the public could sign up to speak. One was at the U.S. Department of Education鈥檚 headquarters in Washington. The other three were in states Trump easily won in 2016: Alabama, Kentucky, and Wyoming. At least one of those states鈥擶yoming鈥攁llow school employees to carry firearms on school grounds, as long as they have a permit and permission from district leadership.

The commission also held 鈥渇ield hearings鈥� to hear from educators and experts on topics like positive behavior interventions and supports or PBIS, a system of supports and strategies meant to combat behavior problems. The commission members also visited rural districts that arm educators.

DeVos said the commission, which issued some 100 individual policy recommendations, sought input from educators, community members, law enforcement experts, and others in nearly every state and reviewed hundreds of comments.

鈥淭his report is without equal. Without equal in the last 40 years. Without equal in the past 18 years in its significance, originality, and its comprehensive review of the issue,鈥� a White House official told reporters.

Discipline Guidance

The 2014 discipline guidance鈥攋ointly issued by the U.S. Departments of Education and Justice鈥攑ut schools on notice that they may be found in violation of federal civil rights laws if they enforce intentionally discriminatory rules or if their policies lead to disproportionately higher rates of discipline for students in one racial group, even if those policies were written without discriminatory intent.

Both of Obama鈥檚 education secretaries鈥擜rne Duncan and John B. King, Jr.鈥攓uickly blasted any move to rescind that guidance.

鈥淥nce again, the Trump administration turns its back on our most vulnerable and underserved students,鈥� they wrote Tuesday. 鈥淭oday鈥檚 recommendation to roll back guidance that would protect students from unfair, systemic school discipline practices is beyond disheartening. It is also shameful that this administration has chosen to ignore students, educators, families, and advocates who have repeatedly asked to keep this guidance in place.鈥�

But a White House staffer defended the decision.

鈥淥ne of the things that the commission was concerned with what was the recurring narrative that teachers in the classroom or students in the hallways and on campus were afraid because individuals who had a history of anti-social, or in some instances, aggressive, trending toward violent behavior, were left unpunished or were left unchecked,鈥� said a White House official in explaining the recommendation.

DeVos and her team were already considering scrapping the guidance, even before the Parkland massacre. But the issue became part of the safety panel鈥檚 deliberations, in part because in Florida鈥檚 Broward County school district, where Parkland is located, an alternative discipline program had served as a example when the Obama administration announced its directive.

The PROMISE discipline program, created in 2013, required Broward County schools to refer students to an alternative disciplinary program instead of law enforcement for a list of nonviolent offenses. The accused Parkland shooter, Nikolas Cruz, was referred to the program for three days after he damaged a faucet in his middle school restroom. But it is not clear if he attended.

A state panel created to investigate the shooting said in July that the PROMISE program had 鈥渘o bearing on the outcome鈥� and did not affect the gunman鈥檚 ability to purchase firearms, as some had speculated.

Critics of the Obama discipline guidance say the document has had a chilling effect on local decisionmaking. Racial differences in discipline rates can鈥檛 entirely be explained by different treatment in schools, those critics contend. They argue black students are more likely to be exposed to out-of-school factors, like poverty, which can cause them to misbehave more.

Some educators testifying before the safety commission urged the panel to scrap the guidance.

鈥淭he schools can be the repository of some student criminals,鈥� Judy Kidd, the president of the North Carolina Classroom Teachers Association, a political organization for educators meant to provide a counterbalance to the teachers鈥� unions, said at a July commission hearing in Washington.

But supporters of the guidance say it has been instrumental in protecting the civil rights of students who are often overlooked. And the directive has motivated states and districts to re-examine their disciplinary practices, making changes that have benefited all students, they say.

To be sure, school districts and states can continue the discipline policies they鈥檝e set up to respond to the guidance, even if it is rescinded.

Tynisha Jointer, the behavioral health specialist for Chicago Public Schools, is hoping her district stays the course.

鈥淲e鈥檝e done a ton of work to take a more restorative approach to discipline. We will continue to prioritize fostering our whole child,鈥� she said.

She worries that rescinding the guidance would reinforce biases that some educators often unconsciously bring to disciplining nonwhite students.

鈥淲hen a black child is misbehaving, we often times see that black child鈥檚 misbehavior as defiant and deviant. Whereas a white child is exploring, they鈥檙e testing boundaries,鈥� said Jointer, who was one of a group from the non-profit Educators for Excellence who personally implored DeVos to keep the guidance. 鈥淭his will send a message that what we have to do for children of color is punish and manage them.鈥�

Black students are consistently disciplined more often than their peers, according to a report issued by the Government Accountability Office in April. While black students represented 15.5 percent of public school students in 2013-14, they made up 39 percent of students suspended, the report said.

Arming Staff

The report鈥檚 support for arming 鈥渟pecially selected and trained school personnel鈥� comes as no surprise.

Trump called for arming school staff鈥攁n idea pushed by the National Rifle Association鈥攅ven before he set up the commission in March.

鈥淎 teacher would have shot the hell out of him before he knew what happened,鈥� Trump said, referring to the former student who is accused of the Parkland slayings.

Trump also suggested that the federal government should consider giving districts grants to cover bonus pay for armed educators.

Under the DeVos Education Department鈥檚 interpretation of the Every Student Succeeds Act, it鈥檚 up to states to decide whether districts can allocate federal money to purchase firearms or train teachers to use them. Democrats in Congress dispute that reading of the law, including ESSA architects Murray and Rep. Bobby Scott, D-Va., the incoming chairman of the House education committee.

And plenty of educators, advocates, and experts who testified before the safety panel pleaded with members to steer clear of support for arming school staff.

Abbey Clements taught 4th grade at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Conn., on the day in 2012 that 26 students and teachers were killed there.

鈥淚t鈥檚 completely unrealistic to think that an educator [could] take down the gunman without interfering with law enforcement鈥檚 response, or harming or killing other educators, or God forbid, children,鈥� she told the commission at a June listening session in Washington. 鈥淭his is not the movies. This is school.鈥�

But some educators argued that arming staff can be a good option for rural schools located far from first responders.

鈥淏ecause of where we鈥檙e located, the last two sheriffs here in Garland County told me we could expect 20 to 30 minutes wait time if an active shooter situation happened on campus before an officer could be here,鈥� Lake Hamilton, Ark., schools Superintendent Steve Anderson, who carries a gun at school, told the commission at an August hearing in Arkansas. 鈥淲e鈥檙e not willing to take that chance. We need someone to protect our kids.鈥�

Since the Parkland shooting, Florida has acted to allow schools to arm some staff. Under a law passed less than a month after that attack, the state legislature mandated a 鈥渟chool guardian鈥� trained in firearms or law enforcement officer in every school. Sheriff Bob Gualtieri, the Florida sheriff leading the state commission investigating Parkland, said he had a change of heart about his opposition to arming teachers after he learned more about what unfolded inside the high school. But some Parkland teachers and victims鈥� families remain opposed to the idea.

Mental Health

The report highlighted local strategies for expanding mental health, even though it did not suggest new federal resources to cover the costs.

It also recommended schools adopt character education, social-emotional learning programs, and efforts to combat cyber-bullying.

For instance, the report lauded districts and schools that use PBIS. Sixteen states were using it in 500 schools or more, as of August 2015, and nearly every state uses it to some extent, experts say.

Two districts that recently experienced mass shootings also appear to use PBIS to some extent, according to their websites: the Broward County school district, which is home to Stoneman Douglas, and Texas鈥� Santa Fe Independent School District, near Houston, the site of another mass shooting in May.

In its most recent budget, the Trump administration sought to eliminate funding for the ESSA鈥檚 Student Success and Academic Enrichment grants, a flexible pot of money districts can use for bolstering school safety and expanding mental health services.

But Congress countered by increasing that funding to $1.1 billion, a $400 million increase over the previous school year.

Citing research by the U.S. Secret Service, the report noted that school attackers often signal their intentions beforehand. It advocated for threat assessment programs and reporting systems, like Colorado鈥檚 Safe2Tell tipline, to provide students a place to share concerns that their peers may harm themselves or others. Such programs got a shot of funding from the STOP School Violence Act, passed by Congress a month after the Florida shooting.

Scope of Panel鈥檚 Work

Back in March, Trump also tasked the panel with exploring age restrictions for certain firearm purchases, potential repeal of Obama-era guidance designed to address racial disparities in school discipline, rating systems for video games, and character education and 鈥渃onnectedness,鈥� as well as access to mental health treatment.

It was also asked to look at the effects of press coverage on mass shootings, and the 鈥渁ppropriateness of psychotropic medication for treatment of troubled youth.鈥� Oliver North, the president of the NRA, has blamed school shootings on the drug Ritalin, which is used to treat attention deficit hyperactivity disorder.

The people most directly affected by the Florida shooting鈥攆amilies who lost loved ones that day鈥攈ave had a variety of reactions to the federal response. While some have supported Trump鈥檚 emphasis on fortifying schools, others have focused more on calls for stronger gun restrictions.

Fred Guttenberg, who lost his daughter, Jaime, in the shooting, tweeted over the weekend that he had rejected a chance to join other families in reviewing the report鈥檚 findings. He cited a tweet from Trump right after the shooting that suggested the FBI was too distracted by investigating his campaign to properly respond to warnings about the shooter.

鈥淗e chose to lie about what he knew and made the death of my daughter political on the day I buried her,鈥� Guttenberg wrote. 鈥淗e then asked DeVos to start a commission on what happened but NOT to look at guns as a factor. For me, you cannot offer a plan that refuses to look at this critical part. For me, this makes her plan inadequate.鈥�

Andrew Pollack, whose daughter Meadow died in the shooting, called the commission鈥檚 findings 鈥渢he most comprehensive report done after a school shooting by any administration.鈥�

鈥淣o agenda just facts make our schools safe,鈥� he tweeted.