The national discussion about improving school safety evolving from the shootings in Newtown, Conn., reached a pivotal moment last week, as the U.S. Senate began consideration of a school building security, and a Senate committee that would bolster school-based mental-health services.
Although Republican senators threatened a filibuster to keep the Senate from discussing the school building security measure鈥攑art of proposed legislation that deals largely with the higher-profile issue of gun control鈥攃ompromises reached behind the scenes nudged the legislation onto the chamber鈥檚 floor by the end of the week.
The deal that paved the way for the Senate breakthrough centered on some aspects of the gun bill regarding background checks for buyers. It came on the heels of plans for improving school safety from the National Rifle Association and other groups, and followed President Barack Obama鈥檚 in his budget to upgrade security, improve school climate, and boost mental-health-care services for students鈥攕imilar ideas to those he offered in January in response to the Newtown shootings. But those measures are likely to face an uphill battle in a Congress that has proved unfriendly to proposals that .
Indeed, there was speculation that the bipartisan mental-health measure, proposed jointly by Senate education committee Chairman Tom Harkin, an Iowa Democrat, and ranking Republican committee member Lamar Alexander of Tennessee, flew quickly through its first committee discussion because it contains little in the way of new spending.
On the Front Lines
The call for improvements to mental-health-care services has grown since the December shootings in Newtown, when a gunman killed 26 children and employees at Sandy Hook Elementary before shooting and killing himself. Questions have been raised about his mental health and about that of shooters in other episodes of violence. Schools have been declared the front lines for early intervention and detection of mental illness.
At a town hall meeting about gun violence that was hosted by the National PTA last week in Baltimore County, Md., U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan noted that lawmakers must address the country鈥檚 mental-health-care system as part of a comprehensive approach to improving school safety.
鈥淭he vast majority [of those who have committed violent acts at school] have real challenges. So many were themselves bullied,鈥� Mr. Duncan said, noting a recent conversation with a student in the District of Columbia who said he brought a deadly weapon to school because he had been bullied and felt no one listened to him. 鈥淲hen students are struggling, ... someone has to know what鈥檚 going on there.鈥�
Under the Senate committee鈥檚 mental-health proposal, states would be encouraged to provide districts with technical assistance on implementing school-based mental-health programs. The measure makes clear that schools can use Title I money for schoolwide intervention services and to create or update school emergency-management plans. It would also renew a program that offers grants to states, Native American tribes, and nonprofit groups to train school staff and emergency-services personnel to recognize the signs of mental illness and connect students and others with the services they need.
鈥淎ny piece of legislation that鈥檚 going to improve mental-health services, and schools鈥� ability to deliver mental-health services in schools by qualified people practicing within their areas of expertise, we鈥檙e happy about that,鈥� said Kelly Vaillancourt, the director of government relations for the National Association of School Psychologists, based in Bethesda, Md.
In recent weeks, her organization and others collaborated on for improving school safety, and the legislation echoes some of those ideas, she said.
The American Association of School Administrators was less laudatory.
鈥淚f the Senate [education] committee wanted to pass meaningful mental-health legislation, they would need to address staffing shortages, professional development, and funding limitations,鈥� said Sasha Pudelski, the government-affairs manager for the AASA, which is based in Alexandria, Va. 鈥淭his legislation doesn鈥檛 do that. However, if this is the only way Congress can do something related to mental health in schools, it鈥檚 better than nothing at all.鈥�
, released April 10, calls for some of what the AASA wants. It includes requests for $55 million for a program that would help educators become more fluent in understanding and identifying potential mental-health issues in students and $50 million to train new mental-health professionals to work with students and young adults.
Movement on Gun Control
Getting the gun-control measure to the Senate floor was at times an agonizing process to watch. Speaking for hours before the Senate on April 10, Democratic Sen. Chris Murphy of Connecticut of the Sandy Hook massacre, noting, for example, that 6-year-old Noah Pozner, the youngest victim, was an advanced reader for his age and his twin sister escaped the shooting merely by being in a different classroom. Sen. Murphy鈥檚 stories were spread out over multiple stints at the microphone and included an easel with a poster covered in photographs of the 26 students and staff members of Sandy Hook killed on Dec. 14.
In addition, several families of Newtown victims arrived in Washington to press senators into action.
On the same day as Mr. Duncan鈥檚 town hall meeting and Sen. Murphy鈥檚 Newtown recollections, first lady Michelle Obama spoke in Chicago about violence that has plagued that city in recent months, comparing herself with a young woman gunned down in the city days after performing in inauguration events in Washington.
鈥淗adiya Pendleton was me, and I was her,鈥� Mrs. Obama said to a group of business leaders she hoped would donate money to develop more community programs in Chicago鈥攁nd to persuade the Senate to act. 鈥淏ut I got to grow up.鈥�
The gun-control bill calls for $40 million in grants to state and local government agencies that want to upgrade school security by buying lights, fencing, doors, locks, and security cameras. The money could also be used to train teachers and administrators on security and better collaborate with local law-enforcement officials. Districts could also use the funds to set up hot lines or tip lines for 鈥渢he reporting of potentially dangerous students and situations.鈥� Local government agencies would have to provide a 50 percent match for the federal resources.
The National Rifle Association pounced on the Senate compromise over background checks, which had been negotiated by Democrat Joe Manchin of West Virginia and Republican Pat Toomey of Pennsylvania. The senators agreed to expand background checks to gun shows, but exempt personal transactions, say, between family members, from the same kind of vetting.
鈥淎s we have noted previously, expanding background checks, at gun shows or elsewhere, will not reduce violent crime or keep our kids safe in their schools,鈥� the Fairfax, Va.-based NRA said in a letter to the Senate.
The organization鈥檚 remarks came about a week after it unveiled its for improving school safety. The NRA plan calls for schools to arm at least one employee, better secure school buildings, and improve mental-health resources for students, saying that one of those ideas without the other two is insufficient.
NRA Plan
The pro-gun group鈥檚 recommendations immediately drew protests from education groups and had already prompted a pre-emptive strike by a collection of civil rights groups.
Although the decision to add armed personnel is a local one, said Asa Hutchinson, who runs the NRA鈥檚 school safety initiative, during an April 2 press conference, he also said that bolstering mental-health resources at schools and improving building security alone are inadequate steps to ensuring school safety.
鈥淭he presence of armed security in a school is a layer that鈥檚 just as important as a mental-health component,鈥� said Mr. Hutchinson, a former Republican congressman from Arkansas, who also has worked in the U.S. Department of Homeland Security and the Justice Department鈥檚 Drug Enforcement Agency. 鈥淛ust [addressing] mental health鈥攊t鈥檚 inadequate. Armed security without access control鈥攊t鈥檚 inadequate.鈥�
Mr. Hutchinson said he backed off an earlier idea promoted by the NRA shortly after the Newtown killings: using armed volunteers to stand guard at schools. Education leaders he spoke to over the past few months were uncomfortable with the idea, he said.
Existing and future school resource officers should communicate better with local law enforcement, and armed school personnel should have comprehensive training, Mr. Hutchinson said.
The NRA plan does not address limits on gun control or the size of magazines.
鈥淚f you have the firearm on the presence of someone at the school, it will save response times,鈥� Hutchinson said. 鈥淭hat鈥檚 the objective.鈥�
