澳门跑狗论坛

Teaching Profession

Performance-Pay Studies Show Few Achievement Gains

Findings reinforce view that compensation plans require more work.
By Vaishali Honawar 鈥 March 03, 2008 5 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print
Email Copy URL

Includes updates and/or revisions.

A that scrutinize performance-pay initiatives nationwide have found mixed results on how they affect student achievement. That conclusion reinforces views that more work is needed on such plans, despite a recent surge in their popularity, before they can replace the traditional single salary schedule.

At a recent conference here organized by the at Vanderbilt University, some researchers concluded that positive effects of performance-based pay were small or none, while others found varying levels of increases in student achievement.

The most positive results were reported by researchers who studied a small-scale pilot program in Little Rock, Ark., that paid bonuses to teachers for simply raising student test scores鈥攁 model some educators actually warn against because it can force teachers to teach to the test.

Among the programs that did not show large-scale gains was the Missouri career-ladder program, in place since 1987, which uses a mix of teacher performance, tenure, and extra responsibilities to determine bonuses. Researchers, who examined the program鈥檚 effects on student achievement by looking at the mathematics and reading data of more than 500 schools over a nine-year period, concluded that while the program did result in small positive increases in math scores, no significant improvement in reading occurred.

鈥淚f there is a positive effect, it is going to be very small,鈥 said Kevin Booker, a researcher with Mathematica Policy Research in Princeton, N.J., who co-wrote the study.

It concludes that a possible outcome of the program could be that the career ladder could help the districts attract and retain higher-quality teachers.

Calls for Experimentation

In recent years, the single salary schedule, which is fiercely protected by teachers鈥 unions and which sets salary largely by seniority and education credits, has attracted criticism from policymakers under pressure to meet standards under federal education law and eager to hold teachers accountable for student achievement. A number of states鈥擣lorida, Minnesota, North Carolina, and Texas鈥攁nd districts鈥擠enver, Houston, Nashville, and New York City, among them鈥攏ow offer varying versions of performance-pay programs. More states and districts are weighing them.

But observers and educators present at the conference sounded a warning note against rushing to adopt such plans without adequate experimentation.

BRIC ARCHIVE

鈥淚 worry that our enthusiasm for professional pay has gotten way ahead of our knowledge,鈥 said Kate Walsh, the president of the National Council on Teacher Quality, a Washington-based research and advocacy group, pointing to the 鈥渕any failures across the country and some glimmers of hope.鈥

鈥淏oth [national] unions are really not against such plans, but we are against full-scale implementation without experimentation,鈥 Howard Nelson, the lead researcher at the American Federation of Teachers, said of his organization and the National Education Association.

Unintended Consequences

Evidence emerging from the reports presented at the Feb. 27-29 conference demonstrates that some plans can indeed have unintended consequences. For instance, in North Carolina, researchers found that a program that rewards bonuses of $1,500 to teachers in schools that show test-score gains above a specified threshold could have resulted in higher rates of teacher turnover in low-performing schools.

While 70 percent of the schools got bonuses each year, some schools, such as those with higher numbers of minority and high-poverty students, were disproportionately unlikely to get bonuses. As a result, researchers said, teachers could view jobs in advantaged schools as more attractive.

The study also found that the program, in effect since 1996, resulted in an improvement in overall test scores, particularly in math, but there was less evidence to show that achievement gaps had narrowed.

Despite those drawbacks, Jacob L. Vigdor, an associate professor of public policy and economics at Duke University in Durham, N.C., said the program has been politically popular. Teachers in the right-to-work state, he said, also widely support the program and want to see the bonuses expanded. 鈥淭hey want every school to participate,鈥 he added.

In Little Rock, meanwhile, a three-year performance-pay pilot program did appear to improve student achievement, more so among students whose teachers were previously less effective at producing learning gains.

BRIC ARCHIVE

Researchers at the University of Arkansas looked at the program implemented at five public schools from 2004 to 2007. The program, said co-author and researcher Jay P. Greene, was remarkably simple: A cash bonus was assigned to an increase in student achievement. There was no evaluation, no professional development, and no supervisory assessment involved.

The results showed that student achievement improved when the teacher became eligible for the bonuses. 鈥淭here is much to be learned, but the initial results are encouraging,鈥 said Mr. Greene.

Teacher Involvement

Some conference participants offered the perspective that models involving teachers from the outset and not relying solely on test scores are the most successful.

A , an education consultant based in San Francisco, concluded that the most comprehensive programs, such as those in Denver, Minneapolis, New York, and Toledo, Ohio, use multiple measures to gauge the extent to which teachers are contributing to increases in student learning. For instance, in Denver, Minneapolis, and Toledo, teachers are paid based on knowledge and skills and the responsibility they assume, as well as student growth.

Ms. Koppich said that all four programs are not punitive, retain echoes of the single salary schedule, and reflect careful planning and transparency.

What鈥檚 more, all are products of joint union-management undertakings, she said.

鈥淭eacher involvement in developing and implementing these programs is essential. Those districts that choose to go behind closed doors and implement programs found they didn鈥檛 work very well,鈥 Ms. Koppich said, noting the importance of bringing teachers鈥 unions on board while considering such plans.

A version of this article appeared in the March 12, 2008 edition of 澳门跑狗论坛 as Performance-Pay Studies Show Few Achievement Gains

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of 澳门跑狗论坛's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Reading & Literacy Webinar
Literacy Success: How Districts Are Closing Reading Gaps Fast
67% of 4th graders read below grade level. Learn how high-dosage virtual tutoring is closing the reading gap in schools across the country.
Content provided by 
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of 澳门跑狗论坛's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Artificial Intelligence Webinar
AI and Educational Leadership: Driving Innovation and Equity
Discover how to leverage AI to transform teaching, leadership, and administration. Network with experts and learn practical strategies.
Content provided by 
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of 澳门跑狗论坛's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School Climate & Safety Webinar
Investing in Success: Leading a Culture of Safety and Support
Content provided by 

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide 鈥 elementary, middle, high school and more.
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.

Read Next

Teaching Profession New Findings on Teacher Morale Highlight Ways to Make It Better
A new College Board survey on teacher morale echoes some previous findings. But it also highlights opportunities for schools to improve it.
4 min read
A student raises her hand to share her work with her teacher.
A student raises her hand to share her work with her teacher.
Allison Shelley for All4Ed
Teaching Profession Opinion Teacher Contracts Need to Change. And It鈥檚 Not Just About Money
If we want to retain effective teaches, we should increase teacher compensation鈥攂ut we need to do it strategically.
Karen Hawley Miles & David Rosenberg
4 min read
Final Piece Of The Puzzle. Two people about to shake hands over trading a jigsaw puzzle piece needed for the solution.
iStock/Getty Images + 澳门跑狗论坛
Teaching Profession The State of Teaching Teachers Say the Public Views Them Negatively
The perception coincides with teachers' low levels of job satisfaction.
2 min read
survey teachers static
via Canva
Teaching Profession Download Play Teacher TV Bingo and Spot All the Teacher Tropes
It's trope bingo; spot the common (and often annoying) mischaracterizations.
Image of bingo cards, a remote control, and a television.
via Canva