Last week, the field of education policy lost an icon. Richard Elmore, a longtime professor at the Harvard Graduate School of Education, played an outsized role in helping the profession better understand the realities of policy when it came to improving schools. He was also an influential mentor of mine, serving on my dissertation committee and helping me get launched in this profession.
And he was one hell of a teacher. I first met Elmore in 1992, when I was a wide-eyed doctoral student who enrolled in his class on education policy. He鈥檇 only been at Harvard for two years at that point, and I was just months removed from teaching. So I didn鈥檛 really know who he was or what I was in for. I left that first class humbled. There must鈥檝e been 50 or 100 students arrayed in the lecture hall, and yet Elmore managed to run a dynamic, provocative, coherent conversation about the ins and outs of policymaking.
He had the ability to invite one thought, then another, and then a third, and then briskly weave them into a clear insight. I still find myself flashing back to his gift when I鈥檓 leading a class or a conversation and struggling to find the point of the matter. It struck me as especially remarkable because he was teaching classes full of impassioned education grad students who saw policy as a way to do huge, wonderful, progressive things. Elmore nonetheless had a knack for asking hard questions, checking the surety of the self-impressed, and imparting practical wisdom, all without seeming hostile.
He taught me much that shapes my thinking. I recall arguing once that something was a terrible idea, that it was like setting fires so firefighters could learn to put them out. Dick pointed out that this is exactly how firefighters do get trained. Twenty-five years later, his understated critique is still with me. It surfaces every time I look at something I鈥檝e drafted and realize that I鈥檓 using a distracting example to make a point or that I鈥檓 not actually yet sure I know what I鈥檓 talking about.
On another occasion, I recall that we were simulating presentations to a school board, with Dick playing the chair. He toyed with me at great length before finally shooting me down. All these years later, I can still remember what he told me when he pulled me aside after class.
He said, 鈥淩ick, you know what your problem was?鈥� I shook my head. 鈥淵ou were going to lose and you didn鈥檛 know it. You were so busy trying to win that you didn鈥檛 bother asking what it would take to convince me.鈥�
鈥淲hat would鈥檝e convinced you?鈥� I asked.
鈥淣othing,鈥� he said. 鈥淵ou were going to lose. And you should鈥檝e known that. That鈥檚 a big part of how this works, asking what others are thinking and what might move them. And you were so busy showboating that you never did.鈥�
It鈥檚 a lesson I carry to this day.
Elmore was, of course, a profound and hugely influential scholar. His insights on the 鈥減roblem of going to scale鈥濃�攚hy promising pilot efforts are so rarely successfully supersized鈥攁re invaluable and color my thinking even now. His notions of 鈥渢ight-loose鈥� governance led a generation of leaders to be more deliberate about which tasks should be centrally controlled and which should not. I think it鈥檚 fair to say he was prescient in arguing that No Child Left Behind-style accountability was hobbled by inattention as to how these mechanisms would drive school improvement.
His passing leaves me both sorrowful and wistful. Despite Dick鈥檚 enormous impact on my thinking and career, we didn鈥檛 keep in close contact over the years. I mostly saw him when I was back up at Harvard teaching or speaking and we鈥檇 bump into one another. Indeed, in his inimitable style, he occasionally let me know that he thought I鈥檇 too often misapplied the lessons he鈥檇 taught me.
But I was touched a couple years ago, after I penned Letters to a Young Education Reformer, when he reached out with a note of congratulations. It was the first time he鈥檇 done that in two decades. He allowed that we might not have seen eye-to-eye at every point of the journey but said he was happy to see I鈥檇 absorbed some wisdom along the way. I regarded that as high praise鈥攁bout the highest I could imagine.
Godspeed, Professor Elmore. You鈥檒l be sorely missed.
