How many children should a person have in public school in order to be qualified to head a state school board?
None, according to Kristin L. Maguire, the mother of four home-schooled children and the chair-elect of the South Carolina board of education, whose recent election to that post has raised some eyebrows in the state.
鈥淚 fully recognize that having someone who home-schools their children serve in this capacity is unique, but at the same time it鈥檚 very disappointing that so much ink has been devoted to critics who have never met me and are wholly unfamiliar with my work,鈥� she said in an e-mail interview.
Ms. Maguire鈥檚 four daughters range in age from 8 to 14 years old and have been home-schooled all their lives.
Ms. Maguire, who holds a bachelor鈥檚 degree in engineering from Clemson University in South Carolina, was elected by her board colleagues on a 9-7 vote over fellow member Fred 鈥淭rip鈥� DuBard, who was the choice of the board鈥檚 nominating committee. She will serve as chair-elect throughout this year, then begin her duties as chairwoman for a one-year term in January 2009.
She was first appointed to the 17-member board in 2000 by her local legislative delegation, and has since been twice reappointed by Gov. Mark Sanford, a Republican.
鈥淜ristin is by far and wide one of the smartest people on the board, and one of the most devoted to public school education,鈥� said Libby W. Swad, the board member who nominated Ms. Maguire for chair-elect. 鈥淲ith someone like Kristin Maguire as the chair, we鈥檒l be able to make some politically courageous鈥攁nd probably unpopular鈥攄ecisions about what to do with education.鈥�
That鈥檚 exactly the fear of critics such as Sheila C. Gallagher, the president of the 13,000-member South Carolina Education Association, an affiliate of the National Education Association.
鈥淚 perceive that [Ms. Maguire] has her own agenda, and that agenda is not what the chairperson of the state board is supposed to come with,鈥� she said.
See other stories on education issues in South Carolina. See data on South Carolina鈥檚 public school system.
Ms. Maguire鈥檚 critics have pointed to her role as a co-founder of , a grassroots organization that supports abstinence-only sex education, the teaching of intelligent design in schools, and tuition vouchers for private schooling.
Ms. Gallagher is also concerned about potential deadlocks because of policy disagreements between Ms. Maguire and state Superintendent of Education Jim Rex.
But Ms. Maguire said she does not anticipate any such problems:
鈥淭here is entirely too much work to be done to make the progress that our state鈥檚 public school children need for either one of us to be distracted by past political differences.鈥�
