It was the cyberattack that wasn鈥檛.
Last year, during the heat of a torturous debate over 鈥渘et neutrality,鈥� the Federal Communications Commission said that its system for accepting online public comments was , described by the agency as 鈥渄eliberate attempts by external actors.鈥�
But now the FCC鈥檚 inspector general has concluded that assertions of an outside attack .
A report released by the agency鈥檚 IG on Tuesday said that rather than a distributed denial of service attack, the disruption to the FCC鈥檚 electronic comment filing system was likely caused by two culprits.The first was 鈥渇lash crowd鈥� activity that followed the urging his viewers in May of last year to contact the agency and weigh in on a proposal by Pai to eliminate an Obama-era net neutrality policy.
The other factor was flawed system design, exacerbated by a high volume of traffic.
The agency鈥檚 Republican chairman, Ajit Pai, was in charge of the commission when it said a cyberattack was behind the disruptions. He issued a this week blaming the agency鈥檚 former chief information officer, who the chairman said was hired by the Obama administration, for providing an inaccurate breakdown of the problem to him and the public.
The disruption of the FCC鈥檚 comment system came last year, when the agency was flooded with public input as Pai and the commission鈥檚 GOP majority moved toward dismantling protections on net neutrality implemented during the Obama administration. Pai鈥檚 plan to reverse the Obama-era policy was ultimately in December in a party-line vote.
Net neutrality is the principle that web traffic should be treated equally by internet service providers so that they鈥檙e not allowed to block or throttle content, or unfairly channel it into fast or slow lanes.
Pai, an appointee of President Trump, has argued that his policy, the 鈥�,鈥� cuts , encourages telecom providers to invest in their networks, and results in better service for consumers.
But school and library officials fear the FCC鈥檚 reversal on net neutrality will give internet providers the power to speed up delivery of content from commercial entities that can afford to pay for faster delivery. Educators, they predict, will be left with slower delivery.
When the FCC made its claim of a cyberattack last year, it was viewed skeptically by opponents of Pai鈥檚 internet order, who believed the agency was trying to cast them as bent on undermining the entire public comment process. The more likely culprit behind the comment system crashing, they argued, was the public鈥檚 overriding interest in protecting net neutrality鈥攃atalyzed around that time by the likes of John Oliver.
鈥楽hortcomings in the System鈥�
The inspector general鈥檚 report said the FCC acted hastily in settling on a cyberattack as the cause.
鈥淩ather than engaging in a concerted effort to understand better the systematic reasons for the incident, certain managers and staff at the commission mischaracterized the event to the office of the chairman as resulting from a criminal act, rather than apparent shortcomings in the system,鈥� the IG report says.
The inspector general also said that some FCC staff members were aware that Oliver was going to air a segment on net neutrality, which was likely to cause a spike in public comments, but they did not share that knowledge.
鈥淗ad such notice been provided, the IT group may have been able to take steps to ameliorate or prevent [public comment system] degradation,鈥� the report said.
In his statement issued Monday, Pai said the agency鈥檚 electronic comment filing system would be redesigned, with funding from Congress.
But he also blamed the agency鈥檚 former chief information officer. Pai said a culture 鈥渨e inherited from the prior administration鈥� discouraged career IT staff from disagreeing with the CIO.
鈥淚n the wake of this report, we will make it clear that those working on information technology at the commission are encouraged to speak up if they believe that inaccurate information is being provided to the commission鈥檚 leadership,鈥� Pai said.
Pai鈥檚 statement did not name the former CIO, though the IG鈥檚 report identifies him as David Bray. 澳门跑狗论坛 could not reach Bray. But in a comment to the publication , provided on behalf of Bray鈥檚 current employer, he said he 鈥渉as not been contacted by the FCC IG and has not seen their reported findings. There has not been any outreach to ask what he had seen, observed, or concluded during the events more than a year ago in May 2017.鈥�
FCC Commissioner Jessica Rosenworcel, a Democrat who opposed Pai鈥檚 policy shift on net neutrality, said the findings of the agency investigation were not surprising.
The report 鈥渢ells us what we knew all along: the FCC鈥檚 claim that it was the victim of a DDoS attack during the net neutrality proceeding is bogus,鈥� Rosenworcel said in a statement. 鈥淲hat happened instead is obvious鈥攎illions of Americans overwhelmed our online system because they wanted to tell us how important internet openness is to them and how distressed they were to see the FCC roll back their rights.鈥�
鈥淚t鈥檚 unfortunate that this agency鈥檚 energy and resources needed to be spent debunking this implausible claim,鈥� she added.
Photo: Federal Communications Commission Chairman Ajit Pai listens to a reporter鈥檚 question after a meeting on Dec. 14, 2017, when the FCC voted to end net neutrality.J acquelyn Martin/AP-File
See also: